Kare Kano

Description

Yukino Miyazawa is a high school student with a pitch perfect image and top grades among his peers. However this is all a deliberate façade to feed her ego, as she’s completely different at home. Things change when another top student, Soichiro Arima, transfers in. Rivalry, friendship and love get entangled in this game of appearances as they learn to accept who they truly are.

Thoughts

I’ll be making an exception for this entry. One of the biggest flaws of this blog is my memory. As I have more projects on the horizon, I just cannot afford to watch a hundred titles and give complex analysis of each one of them and neither is my intention. In reality, my goal is trying to rekindle the emotions and experiences that such titles have brought to me. Even trying to go over them again feels like cheating since I’m not the person I used to be when I watched this or that. It becomes even more of a chore when I factor in that I intend to add even more titles after the 100th milestone. But I’ll be slightly breaking this compromise due to the circumstances of a certain someone else and myself. 

Kare Kano, also known as “His and Her Circumstances”, is a little bit of a mixed bag. Some people love it, some people like it until a certain point and thus they recommend only the beginning and some others are not that fond of it. Personally, I wouldn’t say I’m involved in any community. Moreover, as a big, BIG! fan of the show, I’m even less aware of people who are not fond of the show. Funnily enough, It so happens that I had a hilarious exchange with a great friend of mine this weekend where we talked about the show. He’s a big fan of the manga; which I reckon, it delves way beyond and probably way better into the themes of the story compared to the anime. I knew he didn’t have a good opinion of the show, but oh dear! He came fully prepared to dismantle the Anime into pieces. Me on the other hand, I was just expecting to have a casual talk about it so he caught me completely off guard. I was expecting to have a walk in the park but unfortunately I entered the battlefield and it was quite the experience. Pretty fun not going to lie!

I’m a very agreeable person so I understand where he’s coming from. And although I wanted to avoid involving him in this piece of writing, since I intended to focus merely on Kare Kano and Kare Kano alone, I decided to go hell with it; maybe it makes it more interesting for people who are reading. You know, maybe a little change of pace on how my writing goes doesn’t hurt I hope. So cheers my friend! If “you’re” reading. You’ve left your mark on this blog!

After we ended our conversation I was a little in conflict about how I remembered the show. The truth is, we are on opposite sides. He found the show to be completely stiff, boring and barely animated while I find it to be extremely charismatic, charming and immensely energetic. If there’s something we can agree upon, it’s that the production values are undeniably low, since it’s a fact. Kare Kano was made by studio Gainax in 1998 after they did The End of Evangelion. Something to consider is that although Evangelion is now one of the biggest franchises in Japan and even back then, despite having success in reach and influence, it cost a lot, but A LOT, and there were even legal issues that put the studio in an extremely delicate situation. They took years to recover and the way Gainax organized themselves was always uneven to say the least, or at least that’s how it seems to me as an outsider.

Whenever I do these entries, the only input that I have before writing is watching the opening or trailer, and trying to recall scenes, thoughts, experiences and feelings. After that I  try to portray them as concise and entertaining as possible. So far, I hope I’ve been able to achieve that to a certain extent. If not… I promise I’m trying to improve ;). Regardless, I’ve broken the rule for this one. I followed the routine, watched the linked video of the opening that I had on my list… and I just couldn’t believe the conversation we had. I felt cheated. Kare Kano just has this beautiful vibe that I haven’t seen in any title in my entire life and I absolutely adore it to the core. So I couldn’t help myself and I took a peek into the first episode… It was just as I remember it. It’s such a joy to watch, and maybe it was the first episode so I randomly clicked on the seventh one… the moments are there, what I love is there.

Since I’m bringing other people to the table, let me bring another experience that I had with another friend of mine when I invited him to watch “Akira”, a big classic of anime, to the big screens. I told him that it is one of the best animated movies of all time right after he had asked me such a question. He was disappointed and in disbelief. Is this really one of the best animated films? I explained to him about the amounts of frames, the amount of detail, the impact that it had. But still, he was baffled. He thought it looked ugly, and he thought “Your Name” was better. For fans of Akira, this might be BLASPHEMY! For me though, I see where he was coming from. Again, I’m very agreeable. Everyone has their sensibilities and gravitates to different aesthetics. I can appreciate Akira, and I will always take the chance to see it in the movie theaters if I have the opportunity, but it’s always TOO MUCH DETAIL for me. The characters’ designs fit the world perfectly but… they are more realistic, sort of “ugly”, they are not your standard big eyes, striking figure anime girls and boys all dress in radiant colors, and if that’s not your thing… it’s not your thing.

The friend with whom I had the discussion, said something that I’ve heard as a broken record. Kare Kano doesn’t do what animation is supposed to do, what was the purpose of it even being made. He felt that it was like watching a powerpoint presentation. The animation of Kare Kano is certainly limited. But in my experience I’ve encountered two answers to this approach of seeing animation Which come from my personal journey as a fan of animation and as an artist myself. 

Normally when we speak about animation, we entail the whole product, the voice acting, the sounds, music, timing, pacing, character acting, character designs, layouts, color palettes, the atmosphere, lights and shadows, script, editing, compositing, even the aesthetics and time period that it was created, and so much more that as audience ignore as it should. We can isolate animation for sure and there are works that have sequences that are simply phenomenal, having a flow, rhythm, arcs, secondary motions, weight, etc… Scenes that involve tons of frames, key frames, inbetweens and what have you. But something that I’ve encountered in many titles that really makes me bail out from them, is not only how many frames they might have. There have been plenty of shows which look decently enough but they just feel… boring to me whereas many others seem to really enjoy these.

Something that I don’t like about having watched tons of things is this feeling of Deja Vu. That point when a lot of things start giving you this cookie cutter impression. You start wondering if there’s something wrong with you, which is not really the case. There are so many ways in how you can do something; such as a building, a school, the events of a school, a school club, characters designs, shots, a take on a genre. Additionally, there are already standard processes within the industry to facilitate the work. Even if the staff is doing a good job that I can recognize, it is just time for me to move along and let others enjoy it and not interfere in their experience. There are other times where I do feel that the framing and storyboards are incredibly bare bones. Maybe lack of experience or lack of time, I’ll never know. Nevertheless, scenes where you’re watching a face from a very boring angle, then it cuts to another face on another dull angle and everything lingers awkwardly, and it goes back and forth to the same shots and there’s no real sense of why things are being done the way they are done. It’s just drawings carrying out a script in the most straightforward manner and I’m like… Sorry, I’ll pass!

Despite the limitations the studio had, the amount of dynamism on the storyboard and framing of the shots; How things move in and out of the scene and how they played using limited animation in their favor it’s actually one of my favorite things. The show modulates its speed like a carnival game. It can go extremely fast and stop to a halt. It’s both a visual as it is an audio experience. The cast of actors and actresses is one of the most memorable for me. I believed the studio hired non professional schoolgirls for certain characters to give the show both a more casual and laid back feeling to it and also to make it a little more realistic and relatable. I’m not able to find that bit of information at the moment but the whole cast feels very in tune playing to each other incredibly well. The sound design complements the comedy masterfully, and the soundtrack is by none other than Shiro Sagisu which oscillates from bombastic cheerfulness to melancholic and sorrowful and it’s such a treat. 

I would define the style of the show very vignette centric. It goes from one vignette to the next one. It is as  if the manga suddenly had become sentient and had a life of its own. You’re having this silly conversation with small chibi characters, and boom, a serious onomatopoeia; Something is about to change. A serious argument is going on, the core of the issue gets tossed around. Suddenly the unspoken becomes spoken and the vignette of the vulnerable character appears in no color. This is nothing new per se. It’s actually been done since the 70s. But it’s done so organically and in such a fresh manner that I really haven’t seen anything with the same vibes. All of this tied together with the beautiful and vibrant character designs, adapted from the original work, made by Hiramatsu Tadashi, who also did the designs for FLCL, Abenobashi and Cutie Honey, which I absolutely adore. 

It’s not only that it’s very manga-ish since, that’s pretty much every manga adaptation in some way or another, like DUH!. But it conveys for me a more raw essence. It doesn’t feel like it was just another anime on the pipeline of a studio, where a bunch of adults have to cater to teenagers and they are approaching things from a more methodological point of view. It feels juvenile and I mean it truly as a compliment. The washed out backgrounds, the simplicity of it all as if it was done on a school notebook, the little gags here and there, the exaggerations and mannerisms. There’s this sort of no bullshit attitude that the series breeds, without crossing the line of being edgy or indulgent. It’s silly but down to earth, it’s melodramatic but it takes important things with due respect. The imagery compliments that vibe perfectly, that these are kids who are growing up having both responsibilities and insecurities but at the end of the day, they have fun, they are merely teenagers!

And boy does this anime have gags that will forever be ingrained in my mind. When working with limited animation. You can be sloppy and just throw things in the most careless way unimaginable and you can find hilarious examples on youtube of the worst sequences of anime where it seems they had 1 hour to do everything and they just put whatever they had. On the other hand, you can also be efficient and just focus on doing little workarounds here and there, something that has been done for years and basically these could be the workarounds that have defined anime for many decades. Or you can take the third path and be extremely talented and use the quirkiness and choppiness of a few frames to your advantage and make the most of it. Seeing how they sometimes carefully exaggerate certain expression transitions, followed by another transition that goes from one expression to another with no frames whatsoever, it enhances the absurdity of it all and not everyone can do that so gracefully. You need a great sense of timing and feeling to pull that out constantly and that was just an example of a little thing I noticed in the first episode of just a minor detail.

The MVP of the show really goes to none other than Hiroyuki Imaishi himself. This is where he truly took off and left his mark and displayed what he was capable of. His expertise on gags, and both limited and bombastic animation is just cartoonishly beyond this world. The storyboards that he does are pure immaculate mayhem of joy and silliness. He would later on turn to become a legend creating highly praised titles such as “Kill la Kill” and “Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann” and even his own Studio “Trigger” along Yoh Yoshinari (Who surprisingly didn’t work on Kare Kano). Among him there’s also a dream team of animators, storyboardist, episode directors, animation directors and many more who have delivered moments that I cherished so damn much that sometimes replay in my head and I still laugh or think about. Everyone involved really made this world feel alive and also nostalgic, it feels like traveling back and having a piece of Japan in the 90s as if I was opening an old photo album.

The story

I can’t believe I have to break this into two parts, I really got carried away there isn’t it?

Putting aside my excitement for the production. I haven’t even had the chance to focus on the story.  Romance in anime tends to be sort of a… for lack of a better word… a meme factory… if I can summarize it somehow . Most of them are either a “Will they confess?” or geometric love, triangle, square, hexagon, icosahedron of who will confess first? You also have gravitational black holes A.K.A Harems. In the case that there’s actual relationships, they are about how toxic or insane it can go for maximum train wreck effect. (BTW, If you enjoy any of these, all power to you.) That does not mean that there aren’t anime titles that actually handle relationships without going fully into silly territory, but they are mostly overshadowed by the former examples and in numbers they are few and far between. Kare Kano, it’s one of the most special cases that I’ve encountered in this genre, and although it is not a “one of a kind” in many aspects, it did feel like an out layer and an exception the first time I saw it. And putting all of its ingredients together, It was cooking with things that to this day I really still dig that I see lacking in today’s anime landscape. Although if you want better romances there’s always manga, books or fanfics I guess. So the blame is entirely on me perhaps.  

As I mentioned previously, this work feels as if they wanted to cut the crap. There’s little bullshit in this story, it is just about two teenagers who are having a romantic relationship and have to navigate their own shortcomings. The answer on the title: Is about his and her circumstances (shortened for Kare Kano in Japanese of course). More than romance, I would say it’s an intimate slice of life that spins around these two lovebirds along with their relatives and friends. There’s no this myopic lens that over attaches to the protagonists where the world seems to always and only turn around them. Sure, they are the protagonists and the premise is that they are the top students of the school and because of this they seem to be the center of attention. It fools you like that, but in no time it pulls the rug underneath and it tells you that the story it’s precisely about going beyond that. It’s about understanding the context and environments of these people and looking past those facades.

Compared to many other romances in this media, they quickly accept their feelings, they carry on with their confession, and, what’s this… they have sex! teenagers can have sex? on anime? How shameful! The only reproduction method permissible is through hand-holding! And it’s not morbid or used for low-brow titillation scenes, it’s treated with a lot of warmth and intimacy. It still baffles me how contradictory Japan can be: they want more children, but when it’s about talking about the actual underlying matter they do a 180º, blame something else and pretend the root of the problem doesn’t exist. But in all seriousness, I think I can count on one hand the anime that portray sex scenes in a positive light without it being ecchi or hentai.

But I digress, the amount of themes that are tackled throughout is quite impressive and lovely. The constant pulling force of Kare Kano is all about expectations and identity. It’s about how different people maneuver around these concepts and interact with one another. How much weight do expectations have on you? and how much does that shape your identity? There’s a lot of introspection coming from Yukino and Arima, the main characters, but the series acknowledges that they are not alone as it also spends a lot of time fleshing other characters, like Yukino’s family and their friends in ways that do not impact directly to them but it enriches the world and the themes that are in question. Romance is not the be-all and end-all. It is just something else that happens in this world, is just another tool, another language in how one can interact in such a messy world among many other ways you can interact with it. 

For a show that was made in the late 90s, it feels both conservative and very rebellious. Certain things might seem old fashion nowadays, but in terms of expectations… I’m not really qualified to talk about this even if I already took a jab at this country, but expectations in Japan are hellish as far as no information has shown me otherwise. Kare Kano does a wonderful job at poking at these expectations and it never crosses the line into either extreme. It doesn’t go into full submission of the social norms but neither goes full reckless mode throwing everything outside and burning it to ashes… Although studio Gainax does that… like literally, and I mean “literally” in one episode… I’ll get to that part I promise hahahaha. The show sways like a pendulum from side to side, exploring both the shadows and lights of each issue, and it strives to be assertive, as it doesn’t linger in any particular issue for too much. Even if the problem isn’t solved entirely. Life moves on and it can feel very reaffirming just to change the page when it’s time to do so. This it’s something that I really admire about the show. There are moments that make me smile due to how wholesome the outcomes can be.  

For all of this, my best regards go to the mangaka. I’m not that fond of the manga itself since I’m always missing all of the flourish that got brought along with the anime. But she crafted a magnificent set of characters and explored so many scenarios that sadly… weren’t able to be adapted in the best way. Since there’s an elephant in the room. Despite all of the flowers I’ve thrown at the show, the production was not only rough in terms of money but also in terms of their relationship with the network: It was a complete mess.

If there’s something that studio Gainax is known for… wait I think I’ve said this before… It is known for many things. But among those things. They do things the way they want! Even if they might not know what they want (I’m a big Gainax fan so take this with a bucket of salt please. Don’t take me that seriously, if someone for some reason is doing so). My instinct going by what I’ve read from interviews, a book, articles, seeing analysis, essays, and knowing that there’s a huge disclaimer at the beginning of each episode stating not to watch the television to close to the screen to protect your eyes, tells me that this was a program on a very family friendly time slot which was not very inline with the story neither the intentions of the creators. The show tackles several sensitive subjects that involve different kinds of family and relationship dynamics, some are healthy, some are not. Thus, conflict of interest was sure to follow.  

Hideaki Anno, the director of Evangelion, was assigned to Kare Kano. I don’t remember exactly the story of how this manga particularly got chosen to be adapted, but it wouldn’t surprise me that it had something to do with Anno himself. The story is about expectations and identity, about teenagers understanding their world. It’s about accepting yourself as a sort of coming of age with a romance take on it. There are issues of trauma and self-loathing, Nothing that he hadn’t tackled before on Evangelion or the live action movie he released in the same year, “Love & Pop”. The show itself has tons of trademarks that can be found throughout his repertoire. 

The director himself is a character of his own, he really wanted to move out from animation but he is also someone with an extreme sense of duty and tends to burn himself out because of this. Therefore he didn’t want to leave the studio in a bad spot and without direction. Because of this he took it upon himself to train a new generation of creators using this series as a training ground. What he didn’t expect, or maybe he did, since he is incredibly stubborn, was the fact that he was going to have such a complicated relationship with the T.V network.

Once Hideaki Anno is set on something, making him change his mind is not an easy task. The man has his own ways, for better or worse. He’s both famous and infamous for a reason. Any other person would have taken the constant petitions of the T.V network and say, alright alright, we’ll comply. Anno’s just like… hmmmmm, how do I not comply. At one point he even assigned someone to act as a sort of fake director so that the network could address all of their complaints to this person instead. The point of all of this is that they weren’t in constant struggle with what they wanted to do and what the network wanted. And the more the show moved forward the more the morale went down and the more the show suffered. The pacing slows down, the quality drops and you get a conclusion that is not really a conclusion. And this is why a lot of people love the start but not how it turns midway through the end.

The most evident case of this, might be my favorite episode just because there’s no other case that I know where this has ever happened in the history of anime. Episode 19 :: Episode director :: Imaishi himself. It is deliberately made to look cheap and in budget terms, it definitely is. In terms of creativity though, We’re speaking Imaishi, it’s something else! I don’t think anybody else could’ve pulled that off better than himself. It’s full of photos, cutout characters with just keyframes, colored in crayons, sometimes not even in so-called animation but real footage of characters pasted on wooden sticks moving around. Reused and repurposed shots and sequences and all sorts of antiques. Pretty much a middle finger to the network. And to top it all, in the credits, where normally it’s the beautiful ending theme with live action footage of a school and a camera set on a skateboard, which always changes for every episode. What they chose to film for this one, was to throw everything they did for the episode into a pile and burn it to ashes!… You can make of that whatever you want. After all, what is done is done. As for me, you know what? I’m in. I loved the episode itself and I don’t know of any other studio with the audacity to perform such a feat. If you are already constrained enough, why not pull the chain back as strong as you can and see what happens.

Wrapping everything up together

So going back to the never ending discussion of what should animation be in service for? Was Kare Kano a disservice to the manga and even to animation as my friend put it? You probably already know my answer. HELL NO!!! Animation comes in all forms and shapes and is not an island (My first answer to the animation dilemma) although it can definitively be viewed in a vacuum. The combo that this team delivered, based on the circumstances they had, Is charming beyond so many other titles I’ve seen. It surely depends heavily on limited animation and many techniques to circumvent the issues they faced but it was by no means your run of the mill cutting corners anime. There’s tons of talent in here that I can recognize that took off from here onwards. Whether it will be your style or not, that really depends on your sensibilities. As if this was even supposed to be animated? That’s up to the creators. If the creators want to animate something, then fuck off anyone else who says otherwise (That’s my second answer to the never ending dilemma).

By the end of the conversation, I told my friend that maybe in a parallel universe I would’ve loved to see Kare Kano without the limitations that were imposed by the network and see the show in its full splendor and for it to be the adaptation of the manga that it deserved to be. Don’t take me wrong, 100% I would eat that shit up. But now that I’m thinking back after gathering my thoughts up closely… I wouldn’t give away this version. I love this one because of its strengths AND its flaws. I think it is because of its limitations that it is such a special work. 

I’ve never been to much for the death of the author, I just think is dumb, If I can take both my experiences, the experience of others, the piece of art itself, the context of the creators, the circumstances of the time, and just as much as I can, I’m taking all in! Art is a cumulative experience and Kare Kano in of itself is awesome; is a fascinating experience both from its original source, as it is in its anime form, the time and period it was created, how it was created, as as what came before, and what came afterwards; the people who were behind, as who I was the first time that I watched; the people who have loved this show or the manga as the people who have troubles with it. It’s such an intriguing and whimsical piece of art, and I wouldn’t give it away by any means. To all this, isn’t that the point of the show? Nobody’s perfect, people place too many expectations without understanding what goes behind the curtains of someone else’s life. Isn’t it about learning to appreciate those peculiarities and overcoming the shortcomings?

In some way, it’s ironic, but expectations were precisely the burden for the studio. Maybe there are many who didn’t feel satisfied with the show. However, I’m not one of those. I fit perfectly and snuggly with the beat of its drum. It might be a tough recommendation, but if you feel its calling, either watch the anime or read the manga. I would love for anybody to have a similar experience to the one that I had. I don’t think there’s any other Anime that makes me as gleefully and dreamy as Kare Kano whenever it pops up into my mind. 

Opening